Use cases
For writers: dictation is a drafting tool
Speaking produces words fast and structure slowly. That makes it excellent for first drafts and actively bad for revision — which is exactly how the writers who use it treat it.
Last updated
What changes, honestly
Dictated prose is different from typed prose, and anyone who tells you otherwise has not done it. It is more rhythmic, more conversational, longer-winded, and looser in structure. Sentences run on. Paragraphs lose their edges.
Some of that is a problem to fix in revision. Some of it is an improvement — dictated dialogue is almost always better than typed dialogue, because you are saying it aloud and your ear catches what your eye does not.
| Typing | Dictating | |
|---|---|---|
| Words per hour, first draft | Your typing speed, minus thinking | Two to three times that |
| Sentence rhythm | Even, sometimes flat | More varied, more spoken |
| Dialogue | Often stilted | Usually better — you hear it |
| Structure | You can see the shape as you build it | You cannot. This is the real cost |
| Revision | Natural | Poor. Switch to the keyboard |
| Getting unstuck | Stare at the cursor | Talk about the scene until you find it |
How writers actually use it
- Know what the scene or section is before you start A sentence of intent is enough. Dictation punishes not knowing where you are going more than typing does, because you cannot see the page to orient yourself.
- Dictate in passes of a few hundred words Not a whole chapter. Enough to be a unit, short enough to read back without losing the thread.
- Do not look at the screen while speaking The single most useful habit, and the hardest. Watching the text appear pulls you into editing, and editing while drafting is what dictation is bad at.
- Read it back and fix only the recognition errors Not the prose. Not yet.
- Revise by keyboard, on a different day This is the real workflow. Dictation gets the draft to exist; the keyboard makes it good. Trying to do both by voice is where people conclude it does not work.
The things that ruin it, and the fixes
- Character and place names. Fatal, and entirely fixable. A novel has fifteen proper nouns that appear on every page and no general model has heard of any of them. Teach them once — see building a vocabulary.
- Dialogue punctuation. Automatic punctuation handles quotation marks badly. Say "open quote" and "close quote", or fix it in revision — but decide which, because mixing the two is worse than either.
- Watching the screen. Covered above. It is the habit that decides whether this works for you.
- Expecting clean prose. A dictated first draft is worse than a typed first draft. It also exists, which a typed one often does not.
- Dictating into a cloud service. Your unpublished manuscript is a real asset. On-device recognition means the recording of you reading it aloud is not uploaded to anyone.
Where dictation is genuinely better than typing
- Dialogue. Said aloud, bad lines are obvious immediately. Typed, they survive to the second draft.
- Getting unstuck. Talking about what should happen next, out loud, unsticks scenes that staring does not. Dictate the talking; most of it is rubbish and some of it is the answer.
- Description. Speaking naturally produces sensory detail that typing edits out for being excessive.
- Notes to yourself about the book. The material that never gets written down because it is not the book.
- Anything you are avoiding. The chapter you have circled for three weeks is easier to speak badly than to type well.
A note on where the words go
Dictate into whatever you already write in — Scrivener, Word, Ulysses, iA Writer, Google Docs, a plain text file. A system-wide dictation app types where your cursor is, so there is no importing, no separate app, and no manuscript living somewhere unfamiliar.
For long sessions, latch the microphone rather than holding a key. And keep a local history that includes the audio: when a paragraph comes out mangled, hearing what you actually said recovers it in seconds.
Questions
Can I dictate a novel?
People do, and some very productive writers work this way. The realistic version is dictating the first draft and revising by keyboard. Dictating a finished, structured manuscript in one pass is not how it works for anyone.
Will dictated prose sound different?
Yes — more conversational, more rhythmic, looser. Dialogue usually improves; structure usually suffers. Both are what revision is for.
How do I stop it mangling character names?
Teach them to the app's vocabulary before you start. Fifteen entries covers a novel, and they appear on every page, so the return is immediate.
Does my manuscript get uploaded?
Not with an on-device app like VV — recognition runs on your Mac or PC and the audio is not transmitted. With a cloud dictation service, your unpublished manuscript is being sent to a third party as you speak it.
Does it work in Scrivener?
Yes, and in Word, Ulysses, iA Writer, Obsidian and anything else with a text field, because the app types where your cursor is rather than integrating with each program.